A medal on a cover tells you that some group of judges valued the book for some reason. Knowing who those judges were and what they were asked to look for makes the sticker far more useful.
Different kinds of awards
- Library association awards. The Newbery Medal is awarded annually by the Association for Library Service to Children to the most distinguished contribution to American literature for children;[1] the Caldecott does the same for picture-book art,[2] and the Printz Award recognizes the best young adult titles.[3] Committees of librarians select books; authors do not pay to enter.
- Genre and trade awards from professional organizations, judged by peers or juries.
- Reader's-choice awards, decided by votes.
- Fee-based contests, which authors or publishers pay to enter, often with many categories and honorable mentions. Writers' advocates urge caution about some of these.[4]
The Hollywood Book Festival, whose results this site archives, charged an entry fee and judged on storytelling and adaptation potential. Its honors are real historical facts, but they are a different kind of award from the Newbery or Printz. See our festival history.
Winner, runner-up, honorable mention
Many competitions recognize more than one book per category. In this archive we always keep the three levels separate. An honorable mention is a genuine recognition, but it is not a win — a useful distinction to teach children reading cover stickers.
Talking with children about awards
- Ask who decided. “Who do you think chose this book? What were they looking for?”
- Compare with their own taste. “Do you agree it's the best? What would you have picked?”
- Notice what's missing. Awards favor some kinds of books; great books go unrecognized every year.
- Invent an award. Let them create a family or class award with their own criteria — funniest, scariest, best dog character — and argue for a winner.
For authors considering contests
Before paying an entry fee, look at who judges, how many categories and honorees there are, what the prize is, and what extras are sold to winners. Independent watchdogs such as Writer Beware publish guidance on evaluating contests.[4]
Sources
- John Newbery Medal. Association for Library Service to Children (ALA).
- Randolph Caldecott Medal. Association for Library Service to Children (ALA).
- Michael L. Printz Award. American Library Association.
- Awards Profiteering: The Book Festival Empire of JM Northern Media. Writer Beware (Victoria Strauss), November 15, 2013.
Update history
- 2026-11-17 — Page published in the independent archive.